Have you ever had a slice of authentic Amish pie? If not, you are in for a serious treat because this culture knows exactly how to handle dessert.
Their baking traditions rely on farm-fresh ingredients and simplicity to create incredibly delicious results.
While the recipes are simple, the craftsmanship is undeniable. These 11 recipes are foolproof and guaranteed to make your kitchen smell amazing.
1. Amish Peanut Butter Pie
This pie is supremely rich, creamy, and wonderfully nutty. Every single bite feels like a shot of peanut butter joy straight to the system.
You will absolutely adore this if you are a fan of PB.
2. Amish Chocolate Pie
I am calling on all chocolate lovers to gather round! This silky smooth pie features a decadent filling that practically melts on your tongue.
You get a rich chocolate flavor paired with a buttery crust and plenty of whipped cream.
3. Apple Schnitz Pie
You should try this recipe if you want a truly authentic Amish experience. It is a staple for after church dinners and appears weekly in many communities.
Schnitz just means slices, so this uses thin apple slices rather than chunks to create a tender texture with a tiny bit of crunch.
4. Impossible Pie
I did not understand the name of this recipe the first time I made it. It is actually the opposite of difficult to bake.
The name comes from the magic trick it pulls in the oven where it forms its own crust around the filling.
5. Amish Oatmeal Pie
These are definitely not the oatmeal pies you buy in a box at the store. This homemade version is completely fantastic and uses just eight ingredients.
It tastes sweet and rich like a pecan pie without the nuts.
6. Amish Coconut Cream Pie
Homemade coconut cream pie is one of my absolute favorites. Store bought varieties just cannot compete with the real thing.
This tropical, silky, and creamy dessert requires fewer than 10 ingredients to make.
7. Amish Buttermilk Pie
This dessert has been a favorite for decades because it is quick and easy. The ingredient list is simple and includes staples like sugar, flour, eggs, and buttermilk.
It comes together in just ten minutes before baking for an hour.
8. Amish Whoopie Pies
Think of these treats as giant, soft Oreos. You get two large and fluffy chocolate cookies with a vanilla frosting center.
They are much lighter and more cake like than Moon Pies.
9. Amish Apple Pie
Here is another fantastic recipe everyone should try. This double crust pie features the winning trio of apples, cinnamon, and brown sugar.
Honestly though, the buttery crust is the real star here.
10. Amish Brown Sugar Pie
The name tells you exactly what to expect from this dessert. The filling is a simple mix of brown sugar, evaporated milk, butter, flour, and cinnamon.
It is hard to believe such a simple pie tastes this phenomenal.
11. Amish Pecan Pie
This treat is the definition of ooey, gooey goodness. I love the contrast between the salty, nutty crunch on top and the soft center.
It uses common ingredients to create something wonderfully warm and comforting.
